Review of ‘In the mire: a federal alternative to the Carlist soviet’ by Joan Coscubiela

1pqoiekjf1Democracy hijacked by identity

‘This book is the child of doubt.’ So begins the book by first-time author Joan Coscubiela, offering some insight into the intellectual honesty of this historical and adroit Catalan trade union and communist leader.

And they are not idle words. To acknowledge the practical failure of the two fundamental principles of left-wing politics in the last fifty years can hardly be called insignificant. I am referring to not managing to integrate migrant workers in Catalonia under the ‘one people’ paradigm and the now questioned advisability of exercising the right to self-determination (‘perhaps it is not the wisest thing to do at this time’).

He defended both policies with a passion throughout his long political career, first as general secretary of the Comisiones Obreras union (1995-2008), then as a member of the Spanish parliament (2012-2015) and, finally, as a member of the Catalan parliament (2015-2017).

This is no small exercise in self-criticism by a man well-acquainted with political life in constitutional Spain since its very inception. At the same time, his biography serves as a useful inroad towards understanding the development of the present situation in Catalan society and the actions of its leading political figures from a historical perspective.

Continue reading “Review of ‘In the mire: a federal alternative to the Carlist soviet’ by Joan Coscubiela”

A practical case study of the Catalan press: If this is the truth, wait for the lies!

Hair-raising headlines and fierce, angry statements from celebrities, opinion formers and political leaders followed this news:

Screen Shot 2018-05-20 at 10.50.26
They broke my fingers one by one and groped my boobs, laughing
You furnish any video and I’ll furnish the war! (1)

On the afternoon of 1 October 2017, the La Vanguardia, the most popular newspaper in Catalonia, ran the following story (2):

Continue reading “A practical case study of the Catalan press: If this is the truth, wait for the lies!”

Wake up Government! Leadership also means communicating!


yukrtjgsfbdThe police intervention of Sunday 1 October to prevent Catalan secession left nearly a thousand bruised and battered, and two people in hospital for a few days.

I have desperately tried to discover why the judges and government decided to take such a course of action, but haven’t been able to find anything.

Were the police charges necessary? Was it necessary to prevent voting at the limited number of polling stations operating?

The former Minister of Foreign Affairs stated that Spain lost the communication battle on 1 October.

Continue reading “Wake up Government! Leadership also means communicating!”

Catalonia Referendum: SNP legitimates Spanish stance, but wrongly insists on the ethical principle of self-determination

This is SNP’s statement on the Catalan question:


It can be summed up as follows:

First, it declares that the Spanish government’s position is legitimate:

The SNP Scottish government states that:

1. The Catalan and Spanish governments are perfectly entitled to take positions for and against independence.

It then qualifies its stance by adding an ethical condition:

Continue reading “Catalonia Referendum: SNP legitimates Spanish stance, but wrongly insists on the ethical principle of self-determination”

What nationalists are really after

or when the storm brews…keep calm and check reality
Catalan Public Broadcasting Corporation weather forecast. Note the conspicuous absence of Spain and how the map includes Valencia and the Balearic Islands in Spain, and Roussillon in southern France, more than doubling the size of current-day Catalonia

Quite irresponsibly, everyone seems to be overlooking one all-important aspect of the current political situation in Catalonia.

Almost by the day, we find ourselves on the receiving end of a bombardment of largely insignificant news, for the storm brewing ahead, about the percentage in favour of independence standing at 51 or lowering to 48, or whether an independent Catalonia would form part of the European Union or not…

Now, all this is beside the point and little more than beating around the bush!

Continue reading “What nationalists are really after”

Tarradellas’ prophecy: the origin of the conflict and the big lie

Tarradellas in 1932

I recently spent quite some time carefully reading through the letter which Tarradellas wrote in 1981 about the risks which the ideology and attitude of Jordi Pujol (Catalan President 1980-2003) and its party Convergència i Unió (Convergence and Union) could pose to Catalonia.

Josep Tarradellas was one of the founders of Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya (Republican left of Catalonia) in 1931 and the party leading the ongoing catalán secession movement.

He went on to become a Member of the Catalan Parliament and local Interior Minister in 1932, and then local Finance Minister four years later.

In 1954, he was appointed President of the Catalan Government-in-exile and then named President of the regional pre-autonomy government by Adolfo Suarez in 1977.

After 33 years in exile and aware of the complexity of Catalan society, his first words in the newly reinstated office of President of the Generalidad (Catalan government) proved revelatory of his political thinking and moral values: “Citizens of Catalonia, I am here at last!”, and not “Catalans, I am here at last!”.

This experienced statesman and authority on Catalan political history and its protagonists retired from office in 1980.

In 1981, he wrote a bitter letter to the population airing concerns which he himself admitted were “becoming almost morbid and had him more than worried” (paragraph 33 of the complete letter reproduced below).

Not so much a letter as a prophecy, his missive began with a criticism of Pujol – the president of the Government of Catalonia for the next 23 years- for refusing to permit the traditional “Viva España!” (and “Viva Cataluña!”) at the official handover ceremony the previous year (6).

The letter argues as follows:

Continue reading “Tarradellas’ prophecy: the origin of the conflict and the big lie”